Why I like Spotify…
and why I could like it more.
For a long while now I’ve been a Spotify convert, trading in my library and the consistent foobar2000. Here are the main reasons that i like Spotify and some that make life harder.
1. Free Music
Technically the music isn’t free, either the user subscribes and receives access to certain features or the visual and audio advertisements pay for the music. However, the immediate access to millions of tracks makes this seem like a small price to pay. In a sense Spotify has revolutionised the music industry, reducing the need for ownership – if you are of the inclination that owning digital versions of songs equates to physically owning them. Playlists provide the functionality of the service allowing users to save their favourite streamed tracks for ease of access.
The ‘fairness’ of this business model has been questioned, with it being claimed that Spotify favours major and ‘bigger indie’ labels as they possess equity in the company. Some smaller labels receive ‘no minimum per stream’ and only get a 50% share of ad revenue on a pro-rata basis’ (read the article from last year here)
2. Everything’s in one place.
One of the key problems that Spotify encountered is that in the initial stages where large amounts of music were still being added (as they are to this day) users would have to skip between Spotify and their favourite media players in order to listen to what they wanted to. Now, Spotify functions like a typical – yet simple and stylish – media player and allows users to add their music libraries. There is even a tagging service available to help organise added material.
3. Social Networking
Since Spotify made it possible to import Facebook friends Spotify has become not just a media player but a tool used for sharing and discovery (and it’s legal!). Users can view each other’s listening habits, view/subscribe to each other’s playlists and even recommend music to friends via the ‘inbox’ feature, which also allows attached messages to be added for context. I do think the next step though, is to enable two way messages for the inbox feature. It is often annoying that I can’t reply directly to someone when they take the time to recommend music to me.
4. Last.fm Intergration
While Last.fm offers many of the features that Spotify does, it is nowhere near as convenient in terms of availability of music. However, Last.fm’s all inclusive and user-generated nature means that as soon as a certain piece of music is listened to, it is registered – providing the same people fix the tags and information. This has grand implications for the service Last.fm provides in terms of recommendations, an area which as yet, Spotify has failed to equal. It could be argued though, that with Last.fm intergration, anything beyond the basic recommendations provided by Spotify is just a form fill away.
5. Mobile Use
As is the case for most services now, there are now Spotify app’s for portable devices. This means that users can play music on demand and on the go. Unfortunately, in order to use Spotify on their phones users must be premium subscribers, which I would assume is a put off for many but for those who are willing to pay the potential convenience is unrivaled.
And now for the aspects I don’t like..
1. The advertising
While advertising is the reason this service exists in the model that it does it is also one of its biggest drawbacks and often cited ‘turn offs’ for non users. Specifically, it is the radio type advertisements that I refer to, which given a certain listening scenario, have the potential to be extremely annoying. Imagine you are listening to a concept album, the sudden shift in mood is likely to disrupt the experience. For those simply listening to randomly assembled playlists however, this isn’t likely to be an issue. It is of course a necessary evil for those wishing to avoid subscription fees.
2. Availability of music
While Spotify continues to upload thousands of songs weekly, there are some artists who’s back catalogs are not adequately represented or represented at all for that matter. In order to stream music, licenses must be acquired and for some bands this has not been the case. For some, it is a case of only new material being available but in others if it weren’t for the considerations of licenses in the background, the availability of music would sometimes seem quite arbitrary. On occasion, artists are only represented by entries in compilations that Spotify has acquired the rights to but often, these compilations seem to cease to be available which can be annoying if you’ve added any of the included tracks to playlists.
3. Podcasts
A major drawback for individuals who subscribe to podcasts on a regular basis is Spotify’s inability to download, store and play them. While this remains a key feature of Itunes, Spotify have made it clear that their primary goal at present is to continue to expand their library of music (check out their FAQ) – which in fairness is the core of the service. Spotify users wishing to subscribe to podcasts will have to continue to use external services. There is a similar problem for users wishing to display automated lyrics via Spotify. However, if typing the name of the song into google is too much of a hardship, a 3rd party tool called ‘List DJ’ (semi) adequately displays lyrics and it looks as though it’s part of Spotify.
4. Search ambiguity
While the title of this section says ‘ambiguity’ the Spotify search is not hard to refine. It is however, annoying that instead of being presented with a drop down menu or check box, to search for a specific artist, album or song, the terms must be used as prefix’s (e.g. artist:dinosaur jr.) if accurate results are to be found. Until recently I had just searched the term and trawled through the host of results until I came to the relevant one. While this is a small issue, one of Spotify’s plusses is its minimalist design and ease of use. I can’t help but think a small option for an advanced search, showing users their options and allowing them to filter music would be well received, instead of having to combine search syntax (the list of possible syntax can be found here).
5. Tags
While this is another small grievance, another of Spotify’s annoying tendencies is incorrectly tagged tracks. This seems to be apparent mainly for tracks which include some form of collaboration between artists. (For example, there are various ‘Dan le Sac Vs Scroobius Pip’ tags). The problem here for people who like to scrobble their music is that they can’t edit the tags of spotify hosted songs. This is why I have a number of plays by ‘The Terror Pigeon Dance Revolt‘, a band that don’t exist without an added exclamation mark on the end of their name. In this example though, the incorrectly tagged listing has more listeners than the correct one. I’m guessing that Spotify is the reason. Maybe tighter collaboration between Spotify and Last.fm is needed, they really do compliment each other.
There it is, if anyone has anything to contribute please do so.